A Capehart Scatchard Blog

Court Finds Homeowners May Be Covered for Collapsed Basement Wall Allegedly Caused by Hidden Decay

By on December 5, 2014 in Blog with 0 Comments

Plaintiffs Alexander and Moinica Bardis suffered a loss on December 26, 2009 when the right basement wall of their 20 year old single family home collapsed. They filed a property loss claim against their homeowner’s policy with Cumberland Insurance Group (“Cumberland”). After investigation, Cumberland determined that the loss was not the result of a peril or cause of loss covered by its policy and issued a declination letter. The plaintiffs filed suit in Bardis v. Cumberland Insurance Group, 2014 N.J. Super. Unpub. LEXIS 2414 (App. Div. Oct. 8, 2014), seeking coverage under Cumberland’s policy for this loss.

Cumberland denied the loss, alleging that the collapse was a result of surface and subsurface ground water, weight of ice, sleet, snow and collapse, which is excluded under the policy. Plaintiffs, however, claimed that the basement wall collapsed due to hidden decay and chimney weight deterioration, which is covered by the policy. Although the trial court struck the plaintiff’s expert report as a net opinion, plaintiffs argued that the wall’s collapse, after having stood for so long evinced a gradual decline in strength over the 20 years since its construction, which is consistent with hidden decay, a covered loss.

While the trial court judge granted summary judgment to the defendants, finding no coverage under the policy, the Appellate Division disagreed.

First, the Appellate Division pointed out that there is no definition of the term “hidden decay” in the policy. Using the definition in the dictionary for “hidden decay,” which included a gradual decline in strength, the court used this ordinary meaning in interpreting this term. This approach is consistent with the principle of construing insurance contracts according to the reasonable expectation of the insured. The appeals court found that, arguably, the plaintiffs could have reasonably expected that their homeowner’s policy would cover a gradual decline in strength of their basement wall, followed by its sudden collapse.

The Appellate Division found that based upon the facts of the case, the loss could have been caused by a hidden decay (covered loss) or it could have been caused by improper construction methods (excluded loss). Based upon this fact issue, coupled with the insured’s likely reasonable expectation of coverage for the collapse of a basement wall, the appeals court reversed the trial court’s decision and remanded the matter back to the trial court for trial on these issues. This matter would need to be decided by a jury.


About the Author

About the Author:

Ms. Ramos is an Executive Committee Member and Co-Chair of the Litigation Department at Capehart Scatchard, P.A. located in Mount Laurel, New Jersey. She is an experienced litigator with over 30 years experience handling diverse matters. Practice areas include tort defense, business litigation, estate litigation, tort claims and civil rights defense, construction litigation, insurance coverage, employment litigation, shareholder disputes, and general litigation.

For the years 2020-2023, Ms. Ramos was selected for inclusion in The Best Lawyers in America© in the practice area of Litigation - Insurance. The attorneys on this list are selected based upon the consensus opinion of leading lawyers about the professional abilities of their colleagues within the same geographical area and legal practice area. A complete description of The Best Lawyers in America© methodology can be viewed via their website at: https://www.bestlawyers.com/methodology.

In 2021, Capehart Scatchard and Ms. Ramos received the “Best Law Firm” ranking in the area of Litigation – Insurance (Metro, Tier 3) published by U.S. News & World Report and Best Lawyers®. Law firms included on the list are recognized for professional excellence with consistently impressive ratings from clients and peers. To be eligible for a ranking, a firm must have at least one attorney who has been included in the current edition of Best Lawyers in America, which recognizes the top five percent of practicing lawyers in the United States. Betsy Ramos (Litigation – Insurance) was recognized for this prestigious award in the 2021 edition. For a description of the “Best Law Firm” selection methodology please visit: https://bestlawfirms.usnews.com/methodology.aspx.

“Best Law Firms” is published by Best Lawyers in partnership with U.S. News & World Report. For a description of the selection methodology please visit: https://bestlawfirms.usnews.com/methodology.aspx.

*No aspect of this advertisement has been submitted to or approved by the Supreme Court of New Jersey.


Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.