Permanency
Plaintiff’s Personal Injury Lawsuit From Auto Accident Barred Due to Her Failure to Provide a Timely Certification of Permanency
Plaintiff Renee Ransdell was involved in an automobile accident with defendant Shari Waldron in January 2018. At the time of this accident, plaintiff had an automobile insurance policy which subjected her to the limitation on lawsuit threshold, requiring her to prove a permanent injury to recover damages for her noneconomic loss (i.e., her pain and […]
Plaintiff’s Loss of Balance May Satisfy the Permanency Requirement of the Tort Claims Act
Plaintiff Berta Abreu Flores was injured as a result of a collision by the defendant North Hudson Regional Fire & Rescue Department’s fire engine. During a training exercise, the fire engine crossed the road and struck the front of her residence opposite the fire house where plaintiff was working on the first floor. She claimed […]
Court Finds That Minor’s Left Elbow Fracture May Meet Permanency Requirement of Tort Claims Act
Plaintiff T.R.C. through his guardian ad litem Ada Cardenas filed a personal injury complaint against defendants, Harrison Board of Education, Harrison In District Day School, and the Town of Harrison due to an injury in the preschool program at the Harrison In District Day School. The minor plaintiff, while playing on the playground equipment, fell […]
Plaintiff’s Personal Injury Lawsuit Dismissed As To Public Entity For Failure To Meet Permanency Threshold
Plaintiff, Monica Vargas-Aguacondo, was injured in a motor vehicle accident with a Union County police car driven by defendant David Eckenrode. Plaintiff, age 60, injured her left shoulder and back in the accident. The issue in Vargas-Aguacondo v. Eckenrode & County of Union, 2022 N.J. Super. Unpub. LEXIS 682 (App. Div. Apr. 25, 2022), was […]
Chiropractor’s Report Barred in Automobile Accident Case Due to Inability to Distinguish Between Lumbar Permanency Plaintiff Suffered in Two Different Accidents
Plaintiff Abigail Perdomo claimed to have suffered a lumbar injury causing two disc bulges at L4-5 and L5-S1 in a December 2010 automobile accident. Thereafter, in November 2013, plaintiff was again in an automobile accident and testing showed that she had the same two bulging discs. In Perdomo v. Orgacki, 2018 N.J. Super. Unpub. LEXIS […]



Connect With Capehart Scatchard